Archives

期刊全文

Review of the Editions of Mi Shu Sheng Xu Bian Dao Si Ku Que Shu Mu about the Existing Transmitted Editions

今存傳本系統《秘書省續編到四庫闕書目》版本源流考

Volume / Date

 VOL. 19 (NO. 1) / JUN.2021

Page

 pp. 183-218

DOI

 10.6182/jlis.202106_19(1).183

Language

 Chinese (with English extended abstract)

Sheng-Xiang Yang 楊勝祥

Sheng-Xiang Yang 楊勝祥 Advanced Institute of Confucian Studies, Shangdong University, Jinan, China.
山東大學儒學高等研究院(濟南)
1520538591@qq.com

Abstract

As a bibliography compiled by the government, Mi Shu Sheng Xu Bian Dao Si Ku Que Shu Mu (秘書省續編到四庫闕書目; hereafter Mi Mu秘目), which of great textual value, has a definite source. But there is almost no attention to this bibliography. The important reason is that the edit of Mi Mu is not perfect, while the precondition of the edit is to decide the lineage of the editions of Mi Mu. There are two known edition systems of Mi Mu, the one is the transmitted edition system, another is the incomplete edition system. The editions which can be seen presently all belong to the transmitted edition system. This article is to study the transmitted edition of Mi Mu. By investigation, there are 12 existing editions of Mi Mu in this system. Through collation and evidential research, we can divide these 12 editions into four sub-systems. These four sub-systems are Ji Rui Lou Ben (稽瑞樓本) edition system, Zhang Fu Chuan Cang Ben (張芙川藏本) edition system, Ni En Fu Ben (倪恩福本) edition system, and Ti Zhang Jin Wu Ben (題張金吾本) edition system. By selecting the authoritative edition to collate, we can provide basic research results for Mi Mu’s future study.


《秘書省續編到四庫闕書目》是一部傳承有自的宋代國家修撰目錄，具有重要的文獻價值。但直至今天，《秘目》的研究仍然遠遠不夠。這在很大程度上是因為《秘目》的整理未為完善，而整理的前提是要對《秘目》的版本進行梳理。今可考見的《秘目》文本主要有兩大系統，即徐松輯《永樂大典》本系統、今存傳本系統。現今留存的傳世版本較多，都屬於今存傳本系統，有敘次源流的必要。經調查，今存傳本系統《秘目》現存版本有12種。通過版本對校和史料考訂，可將這12種版本分為4個體系(子系統)。分別是稽瑞樓本體系、張芙川藏本體系、倪恩福本體系和題張金吾本體系。從上述版本體系中選擇代表性版本進行校勘，可為《秘目》的整理、考證、研究奠定基礎。

Keywords

Song Dynasty; Mi Shu Sheng Xu Bian Dao Si Ku Que Shu Mu; Mi Shu Sheng; Lost Ancient Book; Bibliography

宋代、秘書省續編到四庫闕書目、秘書省、佚書、目錄